I had three cats. One was 10 y/o and had been with me since high school. The other two were taken because they needed a home. The two kittens were the only kittens in the litter. One was big and had 6 toes, and the other small with just 5 toes.
As they grew, the orange male with 5 toes, stayed small, and was super skinny. The female, white 6 toed, was big.
They were both fixed, and checked by a vet, given shots and dewormed.
One year later, the skinny cat was all bones, but ate the same as the other cats. Fatcat, as we called her, just got fatter. She didn’t eat anymore than the others. She was a fat, polydactal, cross-eyed freak of nature.
Suddenly Skinnycat got sick. Really awful, really fast. I found him laying upstairs, with a blank, unfocused stare. He looked like he had been dead for weeks, but was still alive. His gums were showing, and he made a horrible moaning-like sound. He was definitly on his way out. I brought him to the vet, and they uthenized him, and told me that they didn’t know what happened, and the tests to find out were very expensive.
One year later, I still have Fatcat, and Pat (the old lady of the house). Fatcat is 30lbs. She just lays sprawled out on her back on the kitchen floor, lazily swatting at your ankles as you walk by in hopes you’ll fill her food dish. Her whole life is focused on food. She does not get more food than Pat (who is a relatively skinny cat). I even give Pat food in a closed room, so Fatcat doesn’t eat her share.
The vet told me to cut Fatcat’s food down to about 1/4. I said I thought that seemed like so little. She only gets 1/4-1/2 a cup of food a day, now.
When I restricted her food, like they said, she went bonkers. She was eating the carpet, anything she found on the floor, including slivers of wood, plastic, or fuzz. She yowled and followed us around, and was just going insane. I gave in.
I gave all this info, in hopes that you can get the jist of the whole situation. All that I’ve experienced leads me to believe that in this case, genetics are what caused the abnormalness. I believe they were probably inbred and got some goofy genetics. One was abnormally skinny, while the sister was abnormally fat.
I think the vet is wrong to tell me to restrict her food. I think this is not something that can be helped. Why make her life miserable by taking away her biggest joy? Although, she has become quite a nuisance, and fills the litter box without covering, and often misses it because her massive body hangs over the edge. She also throws up, and has had bloody stool. I have taken her to the vet for those things, and they didn’t know – and it cost me 0 to hear what they didn’t know!
So….freak of nature? Bad genes? What would you do?